Best 5 Insurance Agency in Fort Myers

You are currently viewing Best 5 Insurance Agency in Fort Myers

Living the American dream life is not perfect without insurance. For most Americans insurance played a major role and made a significant impact on their lives. As we experience life, growing through puberty, raising a family or being single blessedness, and even starting your own business, the importance of insurance for a long term plan has become essential in today’s modern society.

Generally, insurance is important, and below are some of the reasons why:

1.Provide protection for you and your family

You work to have a decent standard of living to feed your family. Insurance provides protection from the financial crisis if unexpected happens.  

2.Lessens stress during difficult times

Life offers a lot of uncertainty, unforeseen events like sickness, accidents, or injury, even death can have tremendous emotional stress to the family. Insurance helps the family cope by lessening the burden so that the family can focus on recovery and move on.      

3. Insurance is a Requirement on some States

In some states, insurance is compulsory because it’s the law. A notable example is auto insurance in Wisconsin. Auto insurance helps reduce car accidents from happening.

4. Peacefulness

It anything happens to you, insurance got you covered. Family’s financial security during these modern times of uncertainty is essential.


A lump-sum death benefit will protect the future of your children and their standard of living.

Through the times, the insurance industry has become significantly diversified and developed in different aspects of our lives such as for auto insurance, business insurance, homeowners, renters insurance and flood insurance, liability insurance, condominium association insurance, recreational vehicle insurance, and motorcycle insurance.

Ever since the law permitted companies to have multi-line, multi-state, and even multi-national insurance conglomerates and holding companies, the choice in finding the right insurance company is still a big challenge for most Americans.

Below are the best eight insurance agencies in Fort Myers that can help you decide for the insurance of your choosing:

1.John Perry Insurance


No. of Years in Service:  25 years


Payment method:

Amex, Cash, Check, Diners Club, Discover, Financing Available, Master Card, Visa

General Info:

For more than 25 years, John Perry Insurance has been helping businesses and individuals like you to find insurance policies that are perfect for your needs. Being an independent agency, we have access to multiple insurance carriers. We will quote and compare your information with each company in order to give you the best possible rate. We offer auto insurance, homeowners, renters insurance and flood insurance, business insurance, liability insurance, condominium association insurance, motorcycle insurance, recreational vehicle insurance, and more. 

Other Brands:

Dairyland, Florida Peninsula Insurance Company, Safeway Insurance, MetLife, Nationwide, Foremost, Security First Insurance, Safeco Insurance, Citizens Property Insurance Corp., St. John’s Insurance, Travelers, The Hartford, American Integrity Insurance Group, Universal Property and Casualty Insurance Co., Victoria Insurance, Zurich, Flood Smart, and  National General Insurance. 

2. Perry-Redish Insurance Agency

No. of Years in Service:  20 years


Services: ATV Insurance, Boat Insurance, Business Insurance, Car Insurance, Commercial Insurance, Condo Insurance, Farm Insurance, Flood Insurance, Health Insurance, Home Insurance, Liability Insurance, Life Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance, Property Insurance, Recreational Vehicle Insurance, SR22, and Workers Compensation Insurance. 

Brands: Nationwide Insurance

Payment method:

Amex, Discover, Master Card, Visa

3.Perry John

Services /Brands:

InsuranceAuto InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceLife InsuranceMutual Funds, and Retirement Planning Services. Nationwide Insurance, aaa, independent agents, MetLife, motorcycle insurance, prudential, travelers

Miscellaneous Info:

AKA- Nationwide Insurance Nationwide Insurance/Nationwide Insurance

Other Links:

4. Rosemary Steadman: Allstate Insurance


Services: Allstate Insurance, Auto Insurance, Business, and Commercial Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Life Insurance

Brands: Allstate

General Info:

Customers count on the outstanding financial strength and superior claims service to help protect what they value most. Allstate delivers on its promise. Their outstanding financial strength and superior claims service received an A+ (Superior) rating by AM Best. Quality service, strength, and satisfaction – that’s something I’m glad to be a part of.

5. Direct Auto Insurance


Services: Term Life Insurance|Renters Insurance|Commercial Auto Insurance|Motorcycle Insurance|Car Insurance|SR-22 Certifications|FR-44 Certifications|Roadside Assistance|Emergency Protection Plans|Mexico Auto Insurance|Auto Insurance|Motorcycle Insurance|Nonstandard|SR-22/FR-44 support.

Brands: Direct General Insurance Agency, Inc. d/b/a Direct Auto Insurance

Payment method:

Amex, Discover, Master Card, Visa, Check, Debit

Cost may vary based on how you buy. Not all products, discounts or payment plans are available in all states or distribution channels. Discounts subject to terms & conditions.

General Info:

We offer liability insurance, comprehensive and collision insurance, roadside assistance, and more! Visit us online, in one of our 400+ local offices in Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia. Direct Auto was founded on the belief that everyone should be able to get the coverage they need, the services they want, and the respect they deserve, no matter the circumstances. 

6. Kevin G. Lewis: Allstate Insurance

No. of Years in Service: 35 years

General Info:

As a Personal Financial Representative in Ft Myers, I know many local families. My knowledge and understanding of the people in this community help me provide customers with an outstanding level of service. I look forward to helping families like yours protect the things that are important – your family, home, car, and more. I can also help you prepare a strategy to achieve your financial goals.


Services Categories:

General Info:

Cigna is a global health service company dedicated to helping the people we serve improve their health, well-being, and sense of security.

8. GEICO Insurance Agent


Services: Automobile Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance, Homeowner’s/Renter’s Insurance, Flood Insurance, Mobile Home Insurance, Boat & Yacht Insurance, Property & Casualty Insurance, Umbrella Protection.

Brands: GEICO

Payment method:

All Major Credit Cards

General Info:

Did you know there’s a local GEICO agent in your area? A lot of people don’t, but it’s true! Fred Trelli is your Ft. Myers area local GEICO agent and is here to help you with all of your car insurance needs. Call his office at 239-415-7777 or stop by the office at 12123 South Cleveland Avenue for a free rate quote today. In just a few minutes, you’ll find out how much you could save with GEICO. Plus, you’ll enjoy all that GEICO has to offer and someone close to home to help you with your insurance needs. It’s the best of both worlds! Contact your local GEICO office today for outstanding insurance at a great rate.

Questions to ask when getting a quote for your insurance in Fort Myers, FL.:

1. How many years of service does the insurance company have?   
2. Does the insurance offer multi-platform services from business to personal insurances?
3. Is the insurance company has one-stop-shop insurance services?
4. Does your insurance company has on-the-go-access mobile services like pay your bills, view your insurance cards without logging in, view your policies, and start an auto claim?  
5. Is the company accessible and convenient, or has offices near Fort Myers, FL? 

If all the answers to that above questions are all ‘yes’, John Perry Insurance is the solution.  For your insurance agency needs in Fort Myers Fl., John Perry Insurance is your number one and right choice insurance company. With more than 25 years of insurance service helping businesses and individuals like you to find an insurance policy that’s perfect and suitable for you and your family.

John Perry Insurance is an independent agency and has access to multiple insurance carriers. We will quote and compare your information with each company in order to give you the best possible rate. We offer auto insurancehomeowners, renters insurance and flood insurancebusiness insuranceliability insurancecondominium association insurancemotorcycle insurancerecreational vehicle insurance and more at our Service Areas:  Insurance Agency Bonita Springs, Insurance Agency Cape Coral, Insurance Agency Clewiston, Insurance Agency Fort Myers, Insurance Agency Labelle, Insurance Agency Okeechobee, Insurance Agency Bonita Springs, Insurance Agency Cape Coral, Insurance Agency Clewiston, Insurance Agency Fort Myers, Insurance Agency Llabelle, and Insurance Agency Okeechobee.

Make that decision happen today! Go ahead make the right insurance choice and you’ll see life has a lot to offer. Every day will always be better because John Perry Insurance got you covered!  

Get comprehensive homeowners and flood insurance policies from John Perry Insurance today. Contact us through the following numbers: 863-777-4966 (Clewiston), 239-204-3211 (Fort Myers), 863-588-7336 (Labelle), and 863-824-5393 (Okeechobee).